Below the metro median, inside Marion County, next to a state park. Here is what the numbers actually say.
Start with the map. Filter by price, beds, and neighborhood.
Lawrence is one of the clearest value plays on this site. The median single-family sale is $292,000 year to date — against $320,000 across the whole MIBOR service area. Most of the suburban towns I write about carry a premium over the metro. Lawrence runs about 9% below it.
That buys you something specific: you are inside Marion County, closer to downtown than Fishers, McCordsville, Fortville or Bargersville, next to a 1,700-acre state park, in a school district that has put more than $400 million into its buildings over the past decade. For under $300,000 at the median.
The MIBOR BLC "city" field for Lawrence returns just 17 closings year to date. That is not the Lawrence market; it is a data artifact. Almost every home here lists with Indianapolis as the postal city, so the city field is close to useless for measuring this area.
Every figure on this page is Lawrence Township instead — 1,022 closings, and the geography people actually mean when they say Lawrence. The township had 122,321 residents at the 2020 census; the incorporated City of Lawrence inside it had 49,370. If you see a "Lawrence market report" built on the city field, it is describing seventeen houses. I would rather show you the real number and tell you how I got it.
Prices are flat — $292,000 both years. Volume is up 1.9%. Sellers got 98.5% of list, essentially unchanged. The one number that moved is days on market, from 9 to 16.
That is a stable, liquid market rather than a hot one. Sixteen days is still quick in absolute terms; it is only striking against last year's nine. Inventory drifted up to 2.5 months in September. If you are buying, that combination — flat prices, a bit more time, a bit more choice — is a friendly set of conditions.
Where Lawrence works less well: if you are buying primarily for appreciation, the numbers here are flat and the towns to the north have been moving faster. And Lawrence Township is genuinely varied street to street in a way that Fishers or Fortville are not — housing age, condition and price can change a lot within a mile. That is exactly the kind of thing you want someone walking it with you for.
Every search below is live MIBOR BLC data. Save one and you'll get new matches by email the morning they list.
This is one of the most varied markets on the site. A township of 122,000 people contains everything from sub-$200,000 houses to Geist waterfront, and the difference between two streets a mile apart can be substantial. Price the specific street, not the township.
Around the 1,700-acre state park — trails, golf, the old officers' housing. One of the genuinely distinctive places to live in Marion County, and the park is not going anywhere. Consistently the strongest resale story in the township.
See homes →The northeast corner, where Lawrence Township touches the water. Note this carefully: some Geist addresses are Lawrence Township schools, not Hamilton Southeastern. Buyers moving from Fishers get caught by this constantly.
See homes →The old village in the northeast of the township, with its own elementary school and its own identity. Quieter, close to Geist and to Fortville, and often better value than either.
See homes →The incorporated city inside the township — about 49,000 people with its own mayor, police and services. Worth knowing whether an address is inside the city limits or just inside the township, because the services differ.
See homes →The main east-west spine, running past Lawrence Central and out toward Fort Harrison. Established, convenient, and a wide range of housing stock and price points along a single road.
See homes →The older commercial spine on the south side of the township. The most affordable entry into the area, and the part where walking the specific street with you matters most.
See homes →Neighborhood guides: Feather Cove · Devonshire · Parks at Winding Ridge · Kensington Farms · Avalon Hills
The Metropolitan School District of Lawrence Township serves the township and the City of Lawrence — roughly 17,000 students across 21 buildings, which makes it one of the larger districts in the state.
Lawrence Central, established in 1940, on East 56th Street; and Lawrence North, opened in the 1970s on Hague Road when the township outgrew a single high school. Which one an address feeds is a real factor in what it is worth, so confirm it by address rather than assuming.
Voters approved a $230 million referendum in November 2019 with 67% in favour, and well over $400 million has gone into capital projects across the district over the past decade. Both high schools had gone decades without major renovation before that work.
This is the one that catches people. Parts of the Geist area are zoned to Lawrence Township schools rather than Hamilton Southeastern, and the boundary does not follow anything intuitive. Two houses on the same road can land in different districts. If schools are driving your decision, confirm the specific address — I check this on every showing.
Seventeen hundred acres inside Marion County — trails, forest, a golf course and the preserved Fort Benjamin Harrison buildings. Very few metro areas have something like this this close in, and it is the single biggest reason people who move to Lawrence stay in Lawrence.
This is Lawrence's quiet advantage. You are inside Marion County — noticeably closer to downtown than Fishers, and far closer than Fortville or Bargersville. If a short commute is high on your list and your budget is under $300,000, there is not really a competing answer in this metro.
Indiana caps homestead property tax at 1% of gross assessed value under the circuit breaker, so most owner-occupants land at or near that figure. Rentals and second homes are not capped at 1% and should be modeled separately. Marion County rates and the City of Lawrence's own services are worth reviewing for a specific address — confirm with the Marion County Assessor.
If you want a subdivision where every house was built in the last fifteen years and every street looks the same, go north. Lawrence Township is older, more mixed and more variable — which is where the value comes from, and also why the specific address matters so much here.
1 community in Lawrence has 6 quick move-in or under-construction homes posted on the builder's own site, verified Nov 9, 2026. Its page lists every home, price and builder.
Search new homes in Lawrence · Every new home in Marion County
The median single-family sale price was $292,000 year to date through September 2026, on 1,022 closings, the same as over the same stretch of 2025. That is about 9% below the MIBOR-wide median of $320,000, which most of the north-side suburbs I cover can't say.
Because the MIBOR BLC "city" field for Lawrence returns only 17 closings year to date. Nearly every home here lists with Indianapolis as the postal city, so that field cannot describe the market. Lawrence Township — 1,022 closings, 122,321 residents at the 2020 census — is the geography people mean when they say Lawrence.
The Metropolitan School District of Lawrence Township, with roughly 17,000 students across 21 buildings and two high schools, Lawrence Central and Lawrence North. Note that parts of the Geist area are Lawrence Township schools rather than Hamilton Southeastern — always confirm by address.
Considerably. The year-to-date median is $292,000 in Lawrence Township, against $405,000 in McCordsville and $443,000 in Fishers. Lawrence is also closer to downtown than either.
Stable rather than hot, and that favours buyers. Prices are flat, sellers received 98.5% of list, and homes took a median of 16 days — up from 9 a year ago. Inventory rose to 2.5 months in September.
Part of it. The northeast corner of Lawrence Township reaches the Geist area, and some Geist addresses are zoned to Lawrence Township schools rather than Hamilton Southeastern. This catches buyers moving from Fishers regularly, so confirm the specific address.
A 1,700-acre state park inside Marion County, on the grounds of the former Fort Benjamin Harrison. Trails, forest, a golf course and preserved historic buildings — and one of the main reasons people choose this part of the metro.
I'm Wes Johnston, a Realtor with Trueblood Real Estate. Lawrence is the market where I am most useful, because it is the one where the street matters more than the town — and where the published numbers are easiest to get wrong.
My job isn't to open doors. It's to tell you what a house is actually worth, what's wrong with it, and whether it's the right move for what you're trying to do — then negotiate hard on your behalf and own the process from contract to close.
If you're two years out, that's fine. Most of my best clients started with a question, not a showing.
Indianapolis metro specialist. Committed to your success.
Set up a saved search and you'll get new Lawrence Township listings the day they come on the market — usually a few days ahead of the national sites. No spam, and you can turn it off any time.
Start My Lawrence SearchValues vary more street to street here than anywhere else in the metro, which is exactly where a national algorithm goes wrong. A real valuation based on what's actually selling near you.