Prices held, but homes are taking twice as long to sell and supply is up by half. Here is what changed in New Palestine this year.
Start with the map. Filter by price, beds, and neighborhood.
The price in New Palestine is flat. The median was $389,500 through August, $500 under last year's $390,000, on 140 closings, up from 135. The pace is what moved. Homes took a median of 25.5 days to sell, about twice last year's 13, and months of supply went from 1.9 to 2.9.
Sellers still got 99.0% of list, down a little from 99.4%. So this is still a market where well-priced homes sell near asking. The difference from a year ago is that buyers aren't forced to decide the first weekend.
The town itself is small: 2,744 people in the 2020 Census, up from 1,264 in 2000. It sits in the southwest corner of Hancock County, in Sugar Creek Township, which had 16,495 people. The town is a small part of the township, so check whether a given address is inside town limits.
What you are actually buying: a small town on US 52 with newer subdivisions around it, township parks, and a town center the council has started planning. What you are giving up: services close by today. The planned Kroger's timeline slowed in late 2025, the town center is at the master-plan stage, and the commute is US 52 to I-465, with no interstate interchange in town.
Every search below is live MLS data. Save one and you'll get new matches by email the morning they list.
The 1838 town grid sits on US 52. Most of the growth is in the subdivisions around it and west toward Carroll Road.
The original 1838 plat, 15 blocks and 36 lots, straddles US 52. Town hall is at 42 East Main, and the house the town's founder built at 113 East Main still stands.
See homes →In March 2026 the council approved a $99,500 contract to master-plan about 79 acres of farmland south of US 52. A splash pad, amphitheater, civic space and commercial uses have been floated. Council members called it a preliminary step, and the site has floodway setbacks to plan around.
See homes →A Kroger store was announced for New Palestine in 2025, and local reporting said the timeline slowed that December. I couldn't confirm the location or an opening date, so don't buy a house counting on it.
See homes →Copperstone, near County Roads 500 West and 200 South, has a paved trail through it. D.R. Horton's Fields at Sugar Creek, off Carroll Road, has pickleball, a playground and a pond. Silverthorne's Willow Ridge offers basement options.
See homes →The 88-acre township park on County Road 700 West and the Jacob Schramm Nature Preserve on 600 West. Sugar Creek and its branches run through the township, so check the FEMA flood map for any parcel near them.
See homes →The area is served by New Palestine Community Schools, which covers Sugar Creek and Brandywine townships. It was formerly the Community School Corporation of Southern Hancock County, and you will still see the old name in some records. Confirm the assignment for the specific address.
I found no New Palestine Community Schools operating or capital referendum on the November 3, 2026 ballot. It is not on the state's referendum list. Confirm with the Hancock County election office before you rely on that.
Sugar Creek Township Park has a one-mile gravel trail, disc golf, a ball diamond, a fenced dog park and two shelters. The Jacob Schramm Nature Preserve has a 0.6-mile loop. The town also has a public library branch.
US 52, which becomes Brookville Road, is the route to I-465. One builder puts downtown Indianapolis at about 30 minutes. I'd drive it at your actual start time before you commit, because there is no interstate in town.
Indiana caps homestead property tax at 1% of gross assessed value under the circuit breaker, so most owner-occupants land at or near that figure before any voter-approved referendum rate, which sits outside the cap. Rentals and second homes are capped at 2% and should be modeled separately. Hancock County's local income tax is 1.94%, per the Indiana Department of Revenue's notice effective October 1, 2026. Neighboring Shelby County is 1.7%. Confirm assessments with the Hancock County Assessor.
If you want a hospital, a downtown and I-70 close by, look at Greenfield, where the median is $299,000. If price matters most, Shelbyville's median is $241,250. For new builds across the county, see the Hancock County new home builds page.
The median single-family sale was $389,500 year to date through August 2026, on 140 closings, down 0.1% from $390,000 over the same stretch of 2025.
Somewhat. Months of supply rose from 1.9 to 2.9 in August, and homes took a median of 25.5 days to sell instead of 13. Sellers still received 99.0% of list, so well-priced homes are still selling close to asking.
New Palestine Community Schools, formerly the Community School Corporation of Southern Hancock County. Confirm the assignment for the specific address.
No New Palestine Community Schools referendum was found on the November 3, 2026 ballot. Confirm with the Hancock County election office.
Not necessarily. The town had 2,744 people in 2020, while Sugar Creek Township around it had 16,495. Check whether the specific address is inside town limits.
Builder sites checked September 26, 2026 showed Silverthorne's Willow Ridge from $327,995 and D.R. Horton's Fields at Sugar Creek from $389,900. See the Hancock County new home builds page for the full county list.
I'm Wes Johnston, a Realtor with Trueblood Real Estate, based in Fishers. I cover the whole Indianapolis metro, and every guide on this site is built the same way: MIBOR numbers, public sources, and the trade-offs a listing description won't mention.
My job isn't to open doors. It's to tell you what a house is actually worth, what's wrong with it, and whether it's the right move for what you're trying to do — then negotiate hard on your behalf and own the process from contract to close.
If you're two years out, that's fine. Most of my best clients started with a question, not a showing.
Fishers-based. Honest numbers, every part of the metro. Committed to your success.
With 140 sales so far this year, the right house doesn't come up often. Set up a saved search and you'll get new New Palestine listings the day they come on the market.
Start My New Palestine SearchNot a national algorithm guessing from square footage. A real valuation based on what's actually selling near you, from someone who has been inside those houses.